Home ] Up ] Passages & Ports ] Photo Albums ] Video Clips ] Letters Home ] About Heartsong III ] About Voyaging ] Publications ] Links ] Search ] Contact Us ]

Charts

 

Home

 

 

Paper Charts Versus Electronic Charts

          When we left in 1998, we were paper chart purists.  We bought a chart for every conceivable destination and passage along the first half of our route (from Florida to Australia).  We carried the Maptech electronic charts only as back-up and for planning purposes.  When someone told us they relied primarily on electronic charts, we privately questioned their judgment.  No -- it was stronger than that.  We questioned their seamanship.

          All that changed.

          In Australia in 2001, we bought a combination radar-chartplotter that used the C-Map NT+ electronic chart cards.  They were so accurate and so convenient and so bullet-proof that they changed our entire approach to navigation.  For the remainder of the trip we bought only small-scale (large area) paper charts as emergency back-ups and relied on the electronic C-Map cards as our primary charts.  Because the cards work on both the chartplotter and the computer, we had built-in redundancy.  The only chart-related disaster that could have happened would have been (1) dropping the card overboard! (2) a complete power failure and eventual draining of the laptop battery; or (3) the laptop and chartplotter both failing on passage.  In any of those events, we had the back-up large-area paper charts.  If we were down to one failsafe (if, for example the power failed and we were on laptop batteries, or if the chartplotter failed and we were down to the laptop alone -- actually, we also carried a spare laptop!), we also would have printed out detail charts from the C-Map card to supplement the paper charts for landfall.

          Under the Club C-Map program, we purchased a card for the waters we were currently sailing (each card covers a huge area), plus a card for the very next area.  Then when we would depart an area, we could trade the old card in for a new one for the area beyond, leap-frog fashion.  We kept two or three aboard, so we wouldn't get caught out if there were no reliable mailing facilities nearby for the exchange.  There is a fee for the trades, but it is still a major savings on purchasing every card, and an astronomical savings over purchasing every paper chart for an area.

          Below is a list of electronic and paper charts aboard Heartsong III during the circumnavigation.  It is updated as of Singapore, and I will try to complete the list at some point.

 

Electronic Charts

bulletC-Map NT+ Cards:  Full coverage from Sydney, Australia, to Florida via the Indian Ocean, Red Sea, Mediterranean, and Caribbean.  
bulletMaptech ChartPack 7: The Bahamas
bulletMaptech ChartPack 9: Imray-Iolaire Charts of the Caribbean
bulletMaptech: French Polynesian Islands
bulletNew Zealand complete chartpack (NZ charts)
bulletSelected charts of Thailand (Thai government charts)
bulletMaptech ChartPacks 33-37: Europe & North Africa

Indices & Catalogs

bulletBritish Admiralty Catalog
bulletDMA Catalog Booklets (1-9)
bulletAustralian Index Charts (Southern & Northern)

Paper Charts: Caribbean

Here is the list of Caribbean charts aboard Heartsong III for our particular route.  They are sorted alphabetically by area.

 

Area Title Type Number Notes

ABC Islands

Bonaire and Aruba

Imray

D231

ABC Islands

Curacao

Imray

D232

Caribbean Sea

Caribbean Sea: Central Part

DMA

26001

Incl Colombia, Jamaica, Cuba, Haiti, Panama

Caribbean Sea

North Atlantic Ocean and West Indies

DMAInt

400

Florida to Venezuela (1993)

Leeward Islands

Anegada Passage with Adjacent Islands

DMA

25600

BVI, St. Martin, Anguilla, Saba, St. Kitts, St. Barts

Leeward Islands

Lesser Antilles: Puerto Rico to Martinique

Imray

A

Incl index for larger scale charts this area

Leeward Islands

Anguilla to Dominica

Imray

A3

Leeward Islands

Guadeloupe to St. Lucia

Imray

A4

Includes Dominica and Martinique

Leeward Islands

Anguilla, St. Martin and St. Barthelemy

Imray

A24

Leeward Islands

St. Christopher, Statia, Nevis, Montserrat, Saba

Imray

A25

(May 1992)

Leeward Islands

St. Christopher, Statia, Nevis, Montserrat, Saba

Imray

A25

(May 1996)

Leeward Islands

Barbuda

Imray

A26

Leeward Islands

Guadeloupe

Imray

A28

(March 1997)

Leeward Islands

Anchorages in Guadeloupe

Imray

A281

Leeward Islands

St. Martin Area: Yachtsman’s Planning Chart

VIYC

63-18

2 copies

Panama

Cabo Velas to Punta Mala

DMA

21030

Costa Rica, Panama: Pacific coasts (1980)

Panama

Punta Burica to Cabo de San Francisco

DMA

21033

Panama to Ecuador: Pacific coasts

Panama

Approaches to the Panama Canal

DMA

21602

Panama: Caribbean and Pacific coasts (2 copies: 1980)

Panama

Approaches to Balboa

DMA

21603

Panama: Pacific coast (1981)

Panama

The Panama Canal

DMA

21604

Central Panama; incl Gatun Lake (2 copies: 1995, 1981)

Panama

Gulf of Panama: Panama to Bahia Pina

DMA

21605

Includes Las Perlas Islands

Panama

Puerto Cristobal to Cabo Tiburon

DMA

26060

Panama, San Blas, Panama Canal, Bay of Panama

Panama

Approaches to the Panama Canal

DMA

26066

North (Caribbean) coast of Panama

Panama

Caribbean Sea: Southwest Part

DMA

28006

Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Panama (1992)

Puerto Rico

Bahia de Guanica to Punta Borinquen

Imray

A11

West coast

Puerto Rico

Punta Figuras to Bahia de Guanica

Imray

A12

South coast

Puerto Rico

Cabo San Juan to Culebra Island & Punta Figuras

Imray

A13

Southeast coast

Trinidad

Venezuela & Trinidad: Pt of Spain to Cabo Codera

Imray

D1

W Trinidad, Margarita, N Venezuela, Tortuga, S Grenada

Trinidad

Trinidad to Carupano

Imray

D11

Peninsula de Paria, Testigos, inset Port of Spain

Venezuela

Cabo Codera to Cabo San Roman

Imray

D2

Orchilla, Roques, Aves, Bonaire, Curacao, Aruba, Venezuelan Coast

Venezuela

Carupano to Cumana, and Isla de Margarita

Imray

D12

Venezuela

Islands off the Coast of Venezuela

Imray

D14

Tortuga, Testigos, Blanquilla

Venezuela

Islands off the Coast of Venezuela

Imray

D22

Las Aves, Los Roques

Virgin Islands

Isla de Culebra and Isla de Vieques

Imray

A131

Puerto Rico to Virgin Islands

Virgin Islands

St. Thomas to Virgin Gorda

Imray

A231

A233

Windward Islands

Trinidad to St. Vincent: Grenadine Islands

DMA

25400

(1981)

Windward Islands

Martinique to Trinidad

Imray

B

To E coast Venezuela; incl index Windward Is

Windward Islands

Tobago

Imray

B4

Trinidad & Tobago (May 1997)

Windward Islands

Martinique to Grenada, Tobago & Barbados

Imray

B5

2 copies: Nov 1996, Nov 1992

Windward Islands

Bequia to Carriacou

Imray

B31

Grenadines

Windward Islands

Grenada

Imray

B32

Includes part of Carriacou

Paper Charts: Pacific

Here is the list of Pacific charts aboard Heartsong III for our particular route, which covers New Zealand's North Island only; and in Australia only from Sydney to Darwin.

Area Title Type Number

(C=copy)

Scale Lat -S to N

Long E to -W

Notes

Australia

Coral Sea: Islands&Reefs

?

?

Willis, Saumarez, Cato, Wreck

Australia

Plans in the Nern Territory

Aus

15-O

plans

plans

plans

Cadell St, Cumberland St, Jensen Bay, Gove Harbour, Gugari Rip

Australia

Approaches to Millingimbi Inlet

Aus

16-O

82,000&plan

-12-10

135-06

-11-43

134-44

Incl inlet plan

Australia

Port Essington

Aus

18-O

75,000

-11-25

132-18

-11-00

131-58

Australia

Clarence Strait

Aus

20-O

50,000

-12-11

131-19.5

-11-54.5

130-53

Australia

Approaches to Port Darwin

Aus

26-O

2002

Australia

Plans in Port Darwin

Aus

28-O

10,000&plans

-12-29.5

130-51.5

-12-26

130-48

2002

Australia

Approaches to Bynoe Harbour&Port Patterson

Aus

29-O

50,000

-12-46

130-40

-12-18

130-22

Australia

Approaches to Port Jackson

Aus

197-O

75,000

-34-05

151-39

-33-25

151-09

2001. Port Hacking(Botany Bay) to the Skillion

Australia

Port Jackson

Aus

200-O

20,000

-33-53.5

151-19.5

-33-47

151-06.5

2001. Plan Parramatta River

Australia

Port Jackson (Eern Sheet)

Aus

201-O

7,500

-33-52.3

151-17.8

-33-48

151-14.7

2001.

Australia

Port Jackson (Central Sheet)

Aus

202-O

7,500

-33-52.5

151-15

-33-50

151-09.7

2001.

Australia

Broken Bay

Aus

204-O

40,000

-33-40

151-31

-33-26

151-05

2001.

Australia

Plans in the SW Pacific

Aus

213-O

-31-55

159-20

-31-20

158º55

Australia

Moreton Bay

Aus

236-O

75,000

-27-39

153-32

-26-58

153-04

Brisbane. Plan of Manly Harbour

Australia

Approaches to Hay Point&Mackay

Aus

249-O

75,000

-21-26

149-55

-20-59

149-10

Australia

Cumberland Islands&Whitsunday Passage

Aus

252-O

100,000

-21-00

149-18

-20-02

148-42

Australia

Whitsunday Passage

Aus

253-O

37,500

-20-25

149-04

-20-12

148-41

Australia

Plans in the Whitsundays

Aus

254-O

plans

plans

plans

Hook, Hayman, Hamilton, Dent, Hook Rf, Lindeman, Shaw, Fitzalan Passage

Australia

Approaches to Cairns

Aus

262-O

-17-00

145-44

-16-49

145-51

Incl plan Pt of Cairns

Australia

Plans in N Queensland

Aus

280-O

varies

-14-19

144-20

-13-43

143-40.5

Incl Magpie Reed, Eden Reef, Flinders Group

Australia

Adolphus Channel to Prince of Wales Channel

Aus

292-O

75,000

-10-50

142-49

-10-25

142-08

Australia

Prince of Wales Channel

Aus

293-O

37,500

-10-36.5

142-27.5

-10-23.5

142-07

Australia

Endeavor Strait

Aus

294-O

75,000

-11-02

142-26

-10-37

141-45

Australia

Goods Island to Proudfoot Shoal

Aus

296-O

75,000

-10-47

142-09

-10-22

141-28

Goods Island to Proudfoot Shoal

Australia

Approaches to Thursday Island

Aus

299-O

12,500

-10-36.5

142-15.5

-10-32.5

142-09

Incl anchs Hammond, Goods, Friday

Australia

Golburn Islands to Melville Island

Aus

308-C

Torres. S Arafura Sea, Croker, Melville, Van Diemen

Australia

Cape Moreton to Sandy Cape

Aus

365-O

300,000

-27-00

154-36

-24-23

152-43

Mooloolaba

Australia

N Reef to Pine Peak Island

Aus

367-O

300,000

-23-15

152-50

-21-25

149-30

Capricorn Channel

Australia

Palm Isles to Frankland Islands

Aus

372-C

-18-45

148-40

-17-00

145-45

1993. Incl Flinders Reefs, Hinchinbrook Island

Australia

Frankland Islands to Lizard Island

Aus

373-C

-17-15

146-50

-14-25

145-00

1993. Incl Cairnes.

Australia

Lizard Island to Cape Sidmouth

Aus

374-C

300,000

-14-50

146-10

-13-00

143-35

1993. Incl Princess Charlotte Bay

Australia

Cape Sidmouth to Cape York

Aus

375-C

300,000

-13-29

144-20

-10-38

142-30

1993.

Australia

Torres Strait

Aus

376-C

Torres.

Australia

Bligh Entrance to Eern Fields

Aus

377-C

Torres. Incl Coral Sea, Ashmore Reef, Great NE Ch

Australia

Orangerie Bay to Jomard Entrance

Aus

381-C

300,000

-11-35

152-25

-09-50

149-45

Incl SE Papua New Guinea, N Coral Sea

Australia

Louisiade Archipelago

Aus

382-C

300,000

-12-00

154-50

-10-17

151-55

Incl SE Papua New Guinea

Australia

Booby Island to Cape Wessel

Aus

410-C

1 mil

-17-45

142-00

-07-40

135-30

1985. Incl Gulf of Carpenteria

Australia

Cape Arnhem to Cape Fourcroy

Aus

411-C

1 mil

-14-10

138-00

-08-00

128-30

1996

Australia

Rowley Shoals to Lombok Strait

Aus

414-O

1 mil

-17-30

120-30

-08-05

114-30

Australia

Fraser Island to Cumberland Islands

Aus

426-O

1 mil

-26-00

158-00

-20-30

148-30

Australia

Cape Don to Cape Wessel

Aus

442-O

500,000

-12-20

136-40

--09-30

131-50

Australia

Louisade Arch., Jomard Entr. to Manuga Rfs

Aus

568-C

130,000

-11-22

153-20

-10-39

152-00

Incl Misima, Deboyne, Reynard&S Papua N Guinea

Australia

Plans Coral Sea, Sheet 2

Aus

611-O

75,000

Kenn, Wreck, Cato, Mellish

Australia

Plans Coral Sea, Sheet 1

Aus

612-O

100,000

Saumarez, Frederick

Australia

Marion Reef

Aus

613-O

150,000

-19-38

152-38

-18-43

151-55

Australia

Diamond Passage

Aus

614-O

150,000

-17-52

152-15

-17-00

150-48

Incl plans E Diamond Islet, Turtle Islet

Australia

Plans in Coral Sea, Sheet 3: Flora&Holmes Reefs

Aus

615-O

varies

-18-00

148-40

-16-20

147-40

Australia

Plans in the Coral Sea 4: Osprey, Shrk, Bougainville

Aus

616-)

varies

Australia

Plans in Coral Sea, Sheet 5: SW Islet to Magdelaine Cays

Aus

617-O

150,000

-17-15

150-25

-15-40

149-27

Australia

China Strait & Approaches

Aus

625-C

25,000

-10-39

150-47.5

-10-30.5

150-34

Sariba, Sideia, Samarai Island&S Papua New Guinea

Australia

Cape Arnhem to Cape Wessel

Aus

715-C

150,000

-12-23

137-13

-10-52

136-15

1995.

Australia

Gugari Rip to Cadell Strait

Aus

716-O

150,000

-12-30

136-24

-10-58

135-26

Incl Arnhem Bay

Australia

Port Essington to Cape Hotham

Aus

720-O

150,000

-12-17

132-10

-10-48

131-18

2002

Australia

Port Essington to Snake Bay

Aus

721-O

150,000

-11-40

132-10

-10-45

130-40

Australia

Beagle Gulf & Clarence Strait

Aus

722-O

150,000

-12-37

131-25

-11-40

129-51

2002. Torres. Incl Melville Island, Van Diemen Gulf

Australia

Port Jackson to Port Stephens

Aus

809-O

150,000

-33.53

152.14

-32.36

151.15

Plans Catharine Hill, Lame McQuarie

Australia

Port Stephens to Crowdy Head

Aus

810-O

150,000

-33-13

153-07

-31-44

152-07

2001. Plans Broughton Isl, Sugarloaf Anch, Cape Hawke Harbour

Australia

Crowdy Head to Smoky Cape

Aus

811-O

150,000

-31-53

153-40

-30-49

152-40

2001. Plan Camden Haven

Australia

Smoky Cape to Clarence River

Aus

812-O

150,000

-30-55

153-50

-29-26

152-52

2001.

Australia

Clarence River to Danger Point

Aus

813-O

150,000

-29-36

153-11

-28-09

153-12

2001.

Australia

Point Danger to Cape Moreton

Aus

814-O

150,000

-28-10

154-00

-26-50

153-02

2002

Australia

Sandy Cape to Bustard Head

Aus

818-O

150,000

-24-46

153-17

-23-53

151-45

Bundaberg

Australia

Bustard Head to N Reef

Aus

819-O

150,000

-24-03

152-26

-23-10

150-45

Great Keppel I; Gladstone

Australia

N Reef to Port Clinton

Aus

820-O

150,000

-23-18

152-12

-22-24

150-40

Keppel Isles

Australia

Hydrographers Passage

Aus

821-O

150,000

-21-00

150-34

-19-35

149-36

Australia

Port Clinton to Percy Isles

Aus

822-O

150,000

-22-32

150-58

-21-38

149-25

Australia

Percy Isles to Mackay

Aus

823-O

150,000

-21-40

150-40

-20-52

149-10

Australia

Bailey Islet to Whitsunday Island

Aus

824-O

150,000

-21-00

150-10

-20-10

148-38